Watching Raw this week and seeing the great Brock Lesnar video package, it was even more apparent, as it is with his every appearance, why Brock Lesnar works so well in his role. He's completely real. You can believe that this is the authentic Brock, just with a camera on him. He's a dick. He doesn't give a fuck about you, me, or anyone else. He's superb in his role, more convincing than just about everybody else in WWE by a country mile.
WWE's biggest problem is not being "PG", it's not a lack of talent or potential stars. It's not even the overexposure of TV content or the need to shill the Network. It's the fact that very few guys on WWE TV are actually cool. Why? Because WWE's tendency to force it's stars to be one-dimensional caricatures has never been worse.
Sheamus is a great example. A good worker, certainly, but if you've seen one match or heard one promo, you feel like you've seen everything he can do. WWE doesn't like to give anybody too much depth, but if a new fan asked you to tell him something about this Sheamus guy, what would you say? He's Irish? That's fuckin' captivating. That's not to say that's all Sheamus has to offer, he might be capable of more, but you'd never know. Sheamus never really took as a top guy despite a huge push in 2012, and he didn't show that he was really good enough or had the transcendent charisma to succeed regardless. Scripting is one thing, but the way the guys are scripted is sculpting them in plastic, forcing them into an unnatural mould.
Roman Reigns is about to get the megapush. But all they know how to do is the Sheamus push. The Diesel push. The push of so many guys who never really took at the top - strip away anything other than a look, a tagline, the most generic verbiage imaginable, and have them win all the time and hope for the best. Sometimes that works if they have something unique about themselves, a flavour that just clicks. But they've already started this direction with Reigns, between being smashed over the majority of the time (which is fine) and his "Assess and Attack" promos that couldn't be more bland if they were cut by Bob Backlund in 1993 (which are not). It's going to doom him when it comes time to take the throne, barring a drastic turnaround or change in philosophy, because the fans will inevitably ask themselves why they love him, and they're not going to have enough answers to justify spending their money. Again, at the WWE 2K15 Roster Announcement show on Summerslam weekend, Reigns showed he has far more personality and a good natural charisma, that you'd never know he has by watching Raw every week.
Bray Wyatt and the recently fired Alberto Del Rio both had the same issue when coming into WWE - a brilliant introduction with a hot character that seemed like it has a ton of potential to do great, interesting things. But the character never actually gets out of first gear. They never evolve, those characters don't actually do anything interesting or unique (or "Creative") after stage one. They just show up and do what everybody else does and before long, they become another flower in the garden, and never change. Eventually flowers like that start to smell pretty putrid.
Look at Dean Ambrose, and ask yourself why he's been getting crowd reactions far beyond the level of his push. The answer is because he's himself, and unlike almost everybody else in the entire company, he's fucking cool. Everything he says fits him, he feels different, and this angle with Seth Rollins allows him to act how his character should. He's doing the kind of whacky antics you'd hope an erratic guy like him could do - hiding in the boot of a car to get at people, throwing an ice bucket in Seth Rollins' face and brawling with him out of nowhere. There is actually something to sink your teeth into, and you want to see what he'll do next because this character, unlike Bray Wyatt, ACTUALLY DOES INTERESTING THINGS. And even if he is scripted, he's good enough to not let it typecast him in a one-dimensional manner.
The underlying theme here is that the WWE desperately needs to let the guys be themselves, rather than washing away the idiosyncrasies that makes any great character in the history of any medium special. Let them be more hands-on, to get involved in ideas for their character, to speak with their own voice, pitch their own angles and try their own things.
The nature of WWE Creative is to take that out of the talent's hands to give the company more control. If a talent tries something and fails, then he may fall short and fuck up future company plans if he sinks instead of swims on his own volition. You can also take a guy who may not be able to cut promos or come up with dialogue and put the words in his mouth. Those type of guys do need scripting.
But by taking that ability away, not only are you preventing failure, you're hindering potential success. In 1997, with WCW kicking the shit out the WWF, Vince held a meeting and told the guys that he was going to, within reason, hand the reigns of people's characters over to themselves, because they knew what they needed to be. But today, with nobody succeeding at his expense, even if the product is colder than a polar bear's dick, they'll stay this course. Wrestling is at its best, and its most popular, when the stars on the show are cool. When you as a fan want to feed of that magnetism.
There is not that much cool or interesting about modern WWE to the male audience, and how could there be? How can a person be told how to act by a team of over a dozen people and come off as anything other than one of Vince McMahon's personal action figures instead of an individual who knows exactly who and what he is, to the point you've got to tune in and see him?
Maybe I'm being too hard on WWE. Maybe these guys like Sheamus, Del Rio, Dolph Ziggler, The Miz, Kofi Kingston, Jack Swagger and Big E don't have enough about them, deep-down, to be top guys. Not everybody does. Not everybody has that special personality. I don't believe Seth Rollins has the personality to be a top guy, and even during the height of his popularity earlier this year, I was among the few to say that Cesaro never showed the ability to connect at a main event level.
But you'd got some guys on the horizon that can make a difference. Dean Ambrose is on his way. Roman Reigns has real potential, but they're forcing him into the same path as those before him. Bray Wyatt should still be a big deal, but they don't have any idea what to do with him. Luke Harper is interesting and could be a psycho killer if they had the balls.
But the fans will always compare the current generation unfavourably to stars from the past, if these guys don't have to chance to be themselves. The guys from the past did. And in many cases, that's exactly why they were stars to begin with.
Thursday, 28 August 2014
Saturday, 23 August 2014
SCG Radio Update!
We've been a little slow on the ball updating this site with the podcasts, but here goes!
SCG Radio #8 - The Overrated In Pro Wrestling
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/e4m7is/SCGRadio8-TheOverratedInProWrestling.mp3
SCG Radio #9 - The Highs And Lows of TNA
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/mz6g9q/SCGRadio9-TheHighsAndLowsOfTNA.mp3
SCG Radio #10 - The Good, The Bad & The Ugly of 2000
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/y93ptz/SCGRadio10-TheGoodBadandUglyof2000.mp3
SCG Radio #11 - The G-1 Climax and New Japan Pro Wrestling
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/acnh5x/SCGRadio11-TheG-1ClimaxandNJPW.mp3
SCG Radio #12 - Analysing the nWo
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/yza72e/SCGRadio12-AnalysingthenWo.mp3
SCG Radio #8 - The Overrated In Pro Wrestling
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/e4m7is/SCGRadio8-TheOverratedInProWrestling.mp3
SCG Radio #9 - The Highs And Lows of TNA
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/mz6g9q/SCGRadio9-TheHighsAndLowsOfTNA.mp3
SCG Radio #10 - The Good, The Bad & The Ugly of 2000
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/y93ptz/SCGRadio10-TheGoodBadandUglyof2000.mp3
SCG Radio #11 - The G-1 Climax and New Japan Pro Wrestling
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/acnh5x/SCGRadio11-TheG-1ClimaxandNJPW.mp3
SCG Radio #12 - Analysing the nWo
http://squaredcirclegazette.podbean.com/mf/play/yza72e/SCGRadio12-AnalysingthenWo.mp3
Wednesday, 20 August 2014
The Lantern's Light Is Fading Away
The audience's reaction to his Raw promo was telling, and it isn't the first time a live crowd has been apathetic to Wyatt's verbal jiu-jitsu. As well delivered as it is, his promos are void of substance, much ado about nothing, and the fans are clocking on to it.
Just a few months back, however, Bray felt like the hottest rising star the WWE had, and it was watching SummerSlam that inspired this column, when one of the people I was watching with, a longtime Cena detractor, tried to pin the blame on ol' JC for Wyatt's recent fate, calling him "the career killer", a comment I had to take exception to.
Let's get a few things established about Bray now - firstly, John Cena was THE reason he began to get the reaction he did. Before that, Wyatt wasn't this surefire, ready-to-explode-into-the-atmosphere character it later appeared he could be. Even though the feud itself was slapdash at best in terms of the content, direction and driving theme, the one thing it accomplished was allowing Bray to call attention to the anti-Cena backlash in such a way to tie it into his own momentum, and create the illusion he was on the cusp. The feud ended with Bray's best match thus far, a Last Man Standing match, that Cena won due to Daniel Bryan being injured and the need for him to step back up as the top babyface.
The second Cena was stripped away from Wyatt, Bray immediately began to flounder, and his reactions became less and less impressive. Love it or hate it, it's clear what the fans were responding to in hindsight - while Bray was the beneficiary, Cena was the facilitator.
Now, saying this sounds critical of Wyatt, and it's not. It's simply the nature of the character. These type of characters, the rooted in pure evil, "rare-breed" persona, is reliant on being constantly fed to stay relevant. They are what they are because they are special. They're involved, and involving. They can't be ignored, they are always to be dealt with, a unique presence that we happen to be witnessing at this particular place in time that is always a step ahead of the audience and his opponent. A Raven in ECW. A heel Jake in the WWF. This character exists and thrives because of the situations he finds himself in, that he creates. You have to cater to them, and it's fundamental wrestling booking.
You have this distinctly evil character, he builds up mega heat, and then it gets blown off in the end. Fundamental booking says that this character needs to come back more evil than ever. In other words, he needs to get his heat back. Once the fearsome monster gets what he has coming, what do you have to fear unless he reinforces why he's a terrifying presence? Bray Wyatt, like his predecessors, needs a constant stream of hot opponents or situations, or else he will fail to maintain the level of heat that results in success.
He can't be just another guy, and you can't book him like you do everybody else. He can't flounder in the middle. His entire appeal, and the reason the character works, is because he isn't "just another guy". He's not like every other wrestler, he's special. Once the audience subconsciously realises he's part of the furniture, just like everybody else in tights on the show, then the very basic element that got him over in the first place is lost. All he has to stand out then is his promos. Promos that can only do so much to separate him, when the fans know it's meaningless.
The problem with Bray Wyatt is that this character, as interesting as it could potentially be...doesn't actually do anything. What dynamic angle has this guy given us? "Creative" should be having a field day with this guy with all the manner of whacky human sacrifices, symbolic mind games and whatever else to give an aspect of danger to Bray Wyatt to make him a guy to tune in for every single week to see what he'll do next. And yet, the most memorable angle he's ever done on Raw is when Daniel Bryan beat the shit out of him in a cage.
That's as big a problem as anything. It's harder to get over and become a genuine star right now than it has ever been, because so many of the typical star-making devices mean less now than they did before. The fans need something concrete, but the character is all talk. He can talk about being the eater of worlds, but if you judge him by his actions, he's bluffing, he doesn't act evil. He commits no horrible sins for us to be angry about. He doesn't break any of the established conventions in his actions. He just talks about it.
Chris Jericho, on paper, is not a massive step down, and given the verbal abilities, it should have worked to reheat Bray after the Cena feud. But winning a match alone won't do it. Nor will going 50-50 in wins and losses with Jericho on Pay-Per-View. A half-assed program isn't the answer. Creative needs to do it's job, or Bray needs to come up with some diabolical acts he can perform, and push to do them.
That character needs to be fed to survive. But he's been positively starving since Last Man Standing.
Tuesday, 12 August 2014
Creative Has Nothing For You
Out of sheer curiosity, when was the last time the WWE introduced a new concept?
You know, something different from the status quo, that broke out of the regular annual rotations and interested the masses because they were about to see something unique that they couldn't judge against history. Wrestling fans are often creatures of nostalgia, and comparisons to the past rarely reflect well on the present. So why not give them something uncomparable?
Between 1994-2004, they introduced the Ladder Match, the Hell In A Cell, the Last Man Standing Match, the TLC Match, the Elimination Chamber, Lion's Den Match, Buried Alive, Three Stages Of Hell, as well as bringing back older concepts like the I Quit Match and Empty Arena match to the WWE for the first time, to name just a few. Granted, you also had your Hog Pen matches, so not everything is going to be a slam dunk.
But between 2004-2014, what do we have? They introduced the godawful Punjabi Prison that lasted two matches, and the mess that was the Championship Scramble, which lasted three. Isn't it funny, they've got more people on the creative team than ever before, and there has been less innovation and progression in the product itself than any other point in history. The crown jewel of creativity for the last ten years, easily, is Money In The Bank.
But Money In The Bank has completely outlived it's usefulness. Somewhere between Jack Swagger and Damien Sandow winning the briefcase, or the fact that most of the midcard has held one of the two World titles and ended up back where they started after cashing in Money In The Bank, it's no longer got the potential star making ability it had for the first three years of its existence. It helped push Edge over the top. But that's really all it ever did.
This Sunday, Brock Lesnar should absolutely, without a doubt, beat John Cena for the WWE Title. There is no justifiable reason for Lesnar to lose this match. It was bad enough he lost to Cena at Extreme Rules. But this, this would be horrific. The guy that broke the Undertaker's Streak after twenty three years loses his next match? To the one guy who doesn't need it? Please, no. Of course this does beg the question of what to do with the WWE Championship. After all, Lesnar has limited dates, and only a handful of matches on his deal. Do you keep the WWE Championship off television?
I've battled with this idea, and it might turn out to be a nice, creative idea that doesn't work out logistically. The idea of a new concept taking centre stage while Paul Heyman shows up stroking the championship belt every week is pretty enticing, but a weekly product and house show circuit, as well as Pay-Per-Views to sell, all without a World Title, may well flounder.
But to go with this line of thinking, if they did put the belt on Brock, the upside is that every Lesnar match now becomes even more important than it ever has been. Triple H begins to regret his decision to give Lesnar the chance to win the title, because it shifts the power to Paul Heyman, and Brock only has to defend when he's contracted to fight. Lesnar's future title defenses can be announced well ahead of time, and television can be built around who gets the shot. Around who gets to be the guy to try and break Brock's grip on the title, bringing the belt back to the company because they're disgusted that Lesnar chooses the UFC model of "the superfight" over being there every week.
The Royal Rumble in January is a no brainer. Winner gets Brock at Mania.
But if you have Brock for the Rumble as well (as they did this year), then do something different. Remember the King Of The Ring? A former staple of the WWE's PPV calendar, this one night tournament culminated with one man standing tall, being put over for his major accomplishment. The company shied away from this idea, because historically, tournaments on Pay-Per-View aren't successful. Understandable.
So update it. Modify it. Tweak it.
You may have read on websites or heard via word of mouth over the last few weeks of the G-1 Climax, New Japan Pro Wrestling's annual tournament to determine the number one contender to the IWGP World Title. Without question the last two tournaments have been amongst the all-time best, due to the quality of the matches. But as a booking mechanism, it's perfect for the WWE, especially in a world without the WWE Champion on every show.
Two blocks of wrestlers (lets say ten per block, for argument's sake), in a round robin tournament where everybody faces everybody else in their block in one-on-one matches. 2 points per win, 1 for a draw, 0 for a loss. The two block winners face each other in the climactic final (ideally on Pay-Per-View), with the winner taking the entire tournament.
Why I think this could work is because, quite honestly, these three hour Raws are brutal. They're long, they drag, they're tedious, and while there is sometimes some good wrestling, there is VERY little consequence to any of it. Random pairings, there solely to fill time in between Network plugs and the Stephanie McMahon angles that are more important.
If you hold the tournament over ten episodes of Raw, and it becomes the focus of the promotion, every match has meaning. Every match has consequences. The chase to lead the group grows more and more tense week by week. Add the WWE element of promos from the guys talking about the importance of each match, with budding rivalries sprinkled throughout the tournament, and you've got a unique element to the product you've never had before.
The downside to the idea is the idea of repetition for ten shows, and the "pure sports" element that might turn off some who enjoy their whacky angles. And that's valid. But to me, the idea on paper of a "top babyface versus authority" angle in 2014 is brutal, and more repetitious than anything else. A guy with a Money In The Bank briefcase being foiled from cashing in has been done for years now. There is absolutely nothing fresh about Raw at all in its current form, so you really have nothing to lose, and with the production tools and storytelling capabilities WWE has at their disposal, it could make for a really fun experience.
The use of the "analysts" could become a regular part of Raw, as Renee Young breaks down the matches with the panel. And it isn't like the show has to be exclusive straight matches and no "WWE-ish" traits - you could weave an angle like the current Ambrose/Rollins feud throughout the tournament perfectly, and it would actually mean more because Ambrose would actually be costing Rollins something important when he loses.
With this idea, Raw has a meaning, it's fresh, you can elevate certain guys a little bit, and at the end, you have a fantastic challenger for Brock Lesnar and a big time title match. If the company puts all of its promotional might into making this tournament important, the finals themselves would be a big deal, let alone the winner Vs. WWE Champion Brock Lesnar, the guy that ended the streak.
Maybe it wouldn't work. But as John McClane once said, "At least I'm thinking, Goddammit!"
Hell, even if they don't do a G-1, do SOMETHING. I'm sure it's not an easy job at all, especially with the whims of Vince McMahon, the fact he drives the car no matter what, and the need to produce so much first-run content. But on the surface right now, calling them a creative team is rather magnanimous.
You know, something different from the status quo, that broke out of the regular annual rotations and interested the masses because they were about to see something unique that they couldn't judge against history. Wrestling fans are often creatures of nostalgia, and comparisons to the past rarely reflect well on the present. So why not give them something uncomparable?
Between 1994-2004, they introduced the Ladder Match, the Hell In A Cell, the Last Man Standing Match, the TLC Match, the Elimination Chamber, Lion's Den Match, Buried Alive, Three Stages Of Hell, as well as bringing back older concepts like the I Quit Match and Empty Arena match to the WWE for the first time, to name just a few. Granted, you also had your Hog Pen matches, so not everything is going to be a slam dunk.
But between 2004-2014, what do we have? They introduced the godawful Punjabi Prison that lasted two matches, and the mess that was the Championship Scramble, which lasted three. Isn't it funny, they've got more people on the creative team than ever before, and there has been less innovation and progression in the product itself than any other point in history. The crown jewel of creativity for the last ten years, easily, is Money In The Bank.
But Money In The Bank has completely outlived it's usefulness. Somewhere between Jack Swagger and Damien Sandow winning the briefcase, or the fact that most of the midcard has held one of the two World titles and ended up back where they started after cashing in Money In The Bank, it's no longer got the potential star making ability it had for the first three years of its existence. It helped push Edge over the top. But that's really all it ever did.
This Sunday, Brock Lesnar should absolutely, without a doubt, beat John Cena for the WWE Title. There is no justifiable reason for Lesnar to lose this match. It was bad enough he lost to Cena at Extreme Rules. But this, this would be horrific. The guy that broke the Undertaker's Streak after twenty three years loses his next match? To the one guy who doesn't need it? Please, no. Of course this does beg the question of what to do with the WWE Championship. After all, Lesnar has limited dates, and only a handful of matches on his deal. Do you keep the WWE Championship off television?
I've battled with this idea, and it might turn out to be a nice, creative idea that doesn't work out logistically. The idea of a new concept taking centre stage while Paul Heyman shows up stroking the championship belt every week is pretty enticing, but a weekly product and house show circuit, as well as Pay-Per-Views to sell, all without a World Title, may well flounder.
But to go with this line of thinking, if they did put the belt on Brock, the upside is that every Lesnar match now becomes even more important than it ever has been. Triple H begins to regret his decision to give Lesnar the chance to win the title, because it shifts the power to Paul Heyman, and Brock only has to defend when he's contracted to fight. Lesnar's future title defenses can be announced well ahead of time, and television can be built around who gets the shot. Around who gets to be the guy to try and break Brock's grip on the title, bringing the belt back to the company because they're disgusted that Lesnar chooses the UFC model of "the superfight" over being there every week.
The Royal Rumble in January is a no brainer. Winner gets Brock at Mania.
But if you have Brock for the Rumble as well (as they did this year), then do something different. Remember the King Of The Ring? A former staple of the WWE's PPV calendar, this one night tournament culminated with one man standing tall, being put over for his major accomplishment. The company shied away from this idea, because historically, tournaments on Pay-Per-View aren't successful. Understandable.
So update it. Modify it. Tweak it.
You may have read on websites or heard via word of mouth over the last few weeks of the G-1 Climax, New Japan Pro Wrestling's annual tournament to determine the number one contender to the IWGP World Title. Without question the last two tournaments have been amongst the all-time best, due to the quality of the matches. But as a booking mechanism, it's perfect for the WWE, especially in a world without the WWE Champion on every show.
Two blocks of wrestlers (lets say ten per block, for argument's sake), in a round robin tournament where everybody faces everybody else in their block in one-on-one matches. 2 points per win, 1 for a draw, 0 for a loss. The two block winners face each other in the climactic final (ideally on Pay-Per-View), with the winner taking the entire tournament.
Why I think this could work is because, quite honestly, these three hour Raws are brutal. They're long, they drag, they're tedious, and while there is sometimes some good wrestling, there is VERY little consequence to any of it. Random pairings, there solely to fill time in between Network plugs and the Stephanie McMahon angles that are more important.
If you hold the tournament over ten episodes of Raw, and it becomes the focus of the promotion, every match has meaning. Every match has consequences. The chase to lead the group grows more and more tense week by week. Add the WWE element of promos from the guys talking about the importance of each match, with budding rivalries sprinkled throughout the tournament, and you've got a unique element to the product you've never had before.
The downside to the idea is the idea of repetition for ten shows, and the "pure sports" element that might turn off some who enjoy their whacky angles. And that's valid. But to me, the idea on paper of a "top babyface versus authority" angle in 2014 is brutal, and more repetitious than anything else. A guy with a Money In The Bank briefcase being foiled from cashing in has been done for years now. There is absolutely nothing fresh about Raw at all in its current form, so you really have nothing to lose, and with the production tools and storytelling capabilities WWE has at their disposal, it could make for a really fun experience.
The use of the "analysts" could become a regular part of Raw, as Renee Young breaks down the matches with the panel. And it isn't like the show has to be exclusive straight matches and no "WWE-ish" traits - you could weave an angle like the current Ambrose/Rollins feud throughout the tournament perfectly, and it would actually mean more because Ambrose would actually be costing Rollins something important when he loses.
With this idea, Raw has a meaning, it's fresh, you can elevate certain guys a little bit, and at the end, you have a fantastic challenger for Brock Lesnar and a big time title match. If the company puts all of its promotional might into making this tournament important, the finals themselves would be a big deal, let alone the winner Vs. WWE Champion Brock Lesnar, the guy that ended the streak.
Maybe it wouldn't work. But as John McClane once said, "At least I'm thinking, Goddammit!"
Hell, even if they don't do a G-1, do SOMETHING. I'm sure it's not an easy job at all, especially with the whims of Vince McMahon, the fact he drives the car no matter what, and the need to produce so much first-run content. But on the surface right now, calling them a creative team is rather magnanimous.
Thursday, 7 August 2014
Armchair Quarterback - Rebooking WrestleMania XI
On the WrestleMania List Of Lists I wrote earlier in the year, I stated that this was the second worst WrestleMania in history, and I stand by that. I won't dwell on it, you can read that blog if you so wish. But rather than bury the show for the sake of it, let's have some fun. Was this show really the best they could do at the time?
The roster in 1995 is pretty awful, and depth is a major issue in this historically shitty year. But I'm going to give a shot, making the best of it. This is being booked on the assumption that I have inherited the situation as it was at the start of 1995, with the roster as it was in March.
WWF Title
Diesel (c) Vs. Shawn Michaels w/Sid
This is the only match on the card I'd keep the same.
If Diesel is champion, the only ready made big match challenger he has is Shawn Michaels, which poses a problem because a) the dynamic of the feud was bad with Shawn as the undersized and overmatched heel challenger, and b) the match itself didn't work out as a result. I think this has to be more of a grudge match than it was, in the vain of Taker/Shawn at Ground Zero. I'd have Shawn and Sid beat the living hell out of Diesel with a steel chair in the run-up, and the idea that after all the superkicks, the spotlight hogging, and the assisted beatdowns, Diesel is finally going to get Shawn one-on-one. In the real world, they tried to position them as equals, which was a big mistake. Since they'd paid the cash to get Pamela Anderson, I guess use her here in the same way they did, but she has to be supplemental to the revenge story.
Same outcome, if you're going with Diesel as champ in the first place, he had to win here.
Winner: Diesel
Bret Hart Vs. Lex Luger
Lex turns heel at the Royal Rumble, costing Bret the WWF Title. The bitter, obnoxious Luger starts to show himself in his post-match explanation - last year at the Rumble, the Lex Express hit a Pink and Black brick wall, and the fans chose Bret over him when they tied at the finish. He dropped his Narcissistic way to represent his country, and they spat in his face when he needed them.
As much as it pissed him off, he swallowed the bitter pill to be the nice guy. Then as soon as Bret lost the belt, he immediately was given a chance to get it back against Diesel, while Lex was never given another chance after he got blatantly screwed at Mania X. Luger is an angry, bitter heel in the build to this match, desperate to prove he is better than the Hitman. And in the cheapest, most gutless fashion, he wins, which marks a turn in the character to super obnoxious, holier than thou self-entitled dickhead Luger a la 1989 Total Package, because he "proved" he was right after all. This can continue with Luger either going after Diesel, or continuing the Bret feud all the way through to Summerslam, where the Hitman gets the win.
Bret can "get his win back" over Backlund on one of the In Your House Pay-Per-Views if its actually needed.
Winner: Lex Luger
Lawrence Taylor/Razor Ramon Vs. Jerry Lawler/Jeff Jarrett w/Roadie
Jerry Lawler was perfect for the LT program. He wasn't the most credible guy after the Doink feud, so he really had nothing to lose. He was that perfect heel to antagonise the celebrity and incorporate some of the Kaufman elements again (hell, could even reference Lawler's past fending off outsiders), and his promo work could have made this a bigger deal than it was.
As evidenced by Bigelow, nobody that worked opposite Taylor was going to come out better for it, so I think LT works better in a tag format where his partner gets the shine of being next to him in all the pubicity and promos, a la Hogan and Mr. T. And Razor in 1995 would have benefitted from some celebrity shine to avoid the midcard typecasting a little bit.
I'd keep Razor as IC Champion at the Rumble, but continue the Jarrett/Roadie feud going. Lawler gets eliminated by Doink or the 1-2-3 Kid in the Royal Rumble, and gets the shove on LT for laughing at him. Lawler, Jarrett and Roadie as a heel trio has big potential as their paths cross leading up to the match, the Memphis-style stooging and verbal prodding is ideal for this scenario, and Lawler gets to complain forever about the loss and doesn't get killed off the way Bigelow did.
Winners: Razor and LT
Undertaker Vs. Bam Bam Bigelow
Because lets face it, King Kong Bundy sucked balls. They'd need to do some serious work near the end of 94 and in the beginning of 95 to heat up Bigelow because he'd been treading water in the middle for a while, but this has a lot of potential. There was a standard formula for Taker feuds at the time - bad guy steals the urn, Taker beats him and gets it back.
I'd go a little more hardcore here and have Bigelow beat the shit out of Paul Bearer, giving him three headbutts off the top rope while Taker is restrained or incapacitated by the rest of the Million Dollar Corporation. A Bearer-less Taker goes it alone, until Paul returns just in time at the finish, urn in hand, encouraging Taker to victory.
Winner: Undertaker
Yokozuna Vs. Davey Boy Smith
Was contemplating going with Owen Vs. Davey for a good match and strong win for Owen, but two reasons why I'll go with booking logic over a good match - number one, Yokozuna did barely anything for 1995, as his team with Owen didn't produce a lot of good anyway, and number two, given the big problem in 1995 with a lack of credible heels for Diesel, Yoko is good for one PPV defense at least. Again, they went with Sid and Mabel, people. I'd maybe change Yoko's look up slightly in his big return, make him a bit darker after losing the Casket Match, and give an impressive win over Davey Boy here, a strong midcard face, to help put some steam back on him after he'd been phased down a bit after losing the title in 94.
Winner: Yokozuna
WWF Tag Team Titles
Smoking Gunns (c) Vs. Owen Hart/Bob Backlund
Owen Vs. Davey left me with a Backlund/Yoko team, which is kind of funny in an absurd way, but the matches would be awful, because both Yoko and Backlund needed help for a team to work. Owen and Backlund have the Bret connection from Survivor Series, and I see them being a potential good act together, with Bob as the crazy hyper-intelligent type, with Owen's cocky heel shtick beside it. Gunns lose the belts, and hopefully this team can elevate the belts a bit.
Winners: Owen & Backlund
1-2-3 Kid Vs. Hakushi
This replaces Owen Vs. Davey as the hot action match on the undercard, serves to give Hakushi his first win on a big stage, and sets him up for some good stuff throughout the Summer.
Winner: Hakushi
Heavenly Bodies/Tatanka/IRS Vs. Headshrinkers/Adam Bomb/Bob Holly
The traditional "lets get a bunch of guys on the card" match, just a fun and quick way to open the show, babyfaces get the win.
Winners: Headshrinkers/Car Bombs ¬_¬
Final Thoughts:
Overall, not only do I think this is significantly better than what we got, but it's very plausible that they could have gone this direction just as easily. One of the major problems coming out of the real show was that there were absolutely no heels worth a fuck afterwards, as the babyfaces smoked through them all in the key matches. Here we elevate Razor as a babyface, get some awesome promos with Jerry Lawler, give Bret a hot issue which he sorely needed since he spent his 1995 in the midcard, create a hot new heel in Lex Luger, we give Yoko some heat, we don't eviscerate Bigelow, Taker gets a notch on his belt and MUCH needed good match, the tag titles are set up nicely on an important team, Hakushi heads into the Spring with some steam, and the Diesel/Michaels story gets its blowoff.
And more importantly, no Harris Twins or King Kong Bundy.
The roster in 1995 is pretty awful, and depth is a major issue in this historically shitty year. But I'm going to give a shot, making the best of it. This is being booked on the assumption that I have inherited the situation as it was at the start of 1995, with the roster as it was in March.
Liam O'Rourke's WrestleMania XI
WWF Title
Diesel (c) Vs. Shawn Michaels w/Sid
This is the only match on the card I'd keep the same.
If Diesel is champion, the only ready made big match challenger he has is Shawn Michaels, which poses a problem because a) the dynamic of the feud was bad with Shawn as the undersized and overmatched heel challenger, and b) the match itself didn't work out as a result. I think this has to be more of a grudge match than it was, in the vain of Taker/Shawn at Ground Zero. I'd have Shawn and Sid beat the living hell out of Diesel with a steel chair in the run-up, and the idea that after all the superkicks, the spotlight hogging, and the assisted beatdowns, Diesel is finally going to get Shawn one-on-one. In the real world, they tried to position them as equals, which was a big mistake. Since they'd paid the cash to get Pamela Anderson, I guess use her here in the same way they did, but she has to be supplemental to the revenge story.
Same outcome, if you're going with Diesel as champ in the first place, he had to win here.
Winner: Diesel
Bret Hart Vs. Lex Luger
Lex turns heel at the Royal Rumble, costing Bret the WWF Title. The bitter, obnoxious Luger starts to show himself in his post-match explanation - last year at the Rumble, the Lex Express hit a Pink and Black brick wall, and the fans chose Bret over him when they tied at the finish. He dropped his Narcissistic way to represent his country, and they spat in his face when he needed them.
As much as it pissed him off, he swallowed the bitter pill to be the nice guy. Then as soon as Bret lost the belt, he immediately was given a chance to get it back against Diesel, while Lex was never given another chance after he got blatantly screwed at Mania X. Luger is an angry, bitter heel in the build to this match, desperate to prove he is better than the Hitman. And in the cheapest, most gutless fashion, he wins, which marks a turn in the character to super obnoxious, holier than thou self-entitled dickhead Luger a la 1989 Total Package, because he "proved" he was right after all. This can continue with Luger either going after Diesel, or continuing the Bret feud all the way through to Summerslam, where the Hitman gets the win.
Bret can "get his win back" over Backlund on one of the In Your House Pay-Per-Views if its actually needed.
Winner: Lex Luger
Lawrence Taylor/Razor Ramon Vs. Jerry Lawler/Jeff Jarrett w/Roadie
Jerry Lawler was perfect for the LT program. He wasn't the most credible guy after the Doink feud, so he really had nothing to lose. He was that perfect heel to antagonise the celebrity and incorporate some of the Kaufman elements again (hell, could even reference Lawler's past fending off outsiders), and his promo work could have made this a bigger deal than it was.
As evidenced by Bigelow, nobody that worked opposite Taylor was going to come out better for it, so I think LT works better in a tag format where his partner gets the shine of being next to him in all the pubicity and promos, a la Hogan and Mr. T. And Razor in 1995 would have benefitted from some celebrity shine to avoid the midcard typecasting a little bit.
I'd keep Razor as IC Champion at the Rumble, but continue the Jarrett/Roadie feud going. Lawler gets eliminated by Doink or the 1-2-3 Kid in the Royal Rumble, and gets the shove on LT for laughing at him. Lawler, Jarrett and Roadie as a heel trio has big potential as their paths cross leading up to the match, the Memphis-style stooging and verbal prodding is ideal for this scenario, and Lawler gets to complain forever about the loss and doesn't get killed off the way Bigelow did.
Winners: Razor and LT
Undertaker Vs. Bam Bam Bigelow
Because lets face it, King Kong Bundy sucked balls. They'd need to do some serious work near the end of 94 and in the beginning of 95 to heat up Bigelow because he'd been treading water in the middle for a while, but this has a lot of potential. There was a standard formula for Taker feuds at the time - bad guy steals the urn, Taker beats him and gets it back.
I'd go a little more hardcore here and have Bigelow beat the shit out of Paul Bearer, giving him three headbutts off the top rope while Taker is restrained or incapacitated by the rest of the Million Dollar Corporation. A Bearer-less Taker goes it alone, until Paul returns just in time at the finish, urn in hand, encouraging Taker to victory.
Winner: Undertaker
Yokozuna Vs. Davey Boy Smith
Was contemplating going with Owen Vs. Davey for a good match and strong win for Owen, but two reasons why I'll go with booking logic over a good match - number one, Yokozuna did barely anything for 1995, as his team with Owen didn't produce a lot of good anyway, and number two, given the big problem in 1995 with a lack of credible heels for Diesel, Yoko is good for one PPV defense at least. Again, they went with Sid and Mabel, people. I'd maybe change Yoko's look up slightly in his big return, make him a bit darker after losing the Casket Match, and give an impressive win over Davey Boy here, a strong midcard face, to help put some steam back on him after he'd been phased down a bit after losing the title in 94.
Winner: Yokozuna
WWF Tag Team Titles
Smoking Gunns (c) Vs. Owen Hart/Bob Backlund
Owen Vs. Davey left me with a Backlund/Yoko team, which is kind of funny in an absurd way, but the matches would be awful, because both Yoko and Backlund needed help for a team to work. Owen and Backlund have the Bret connection from Survivor Series, and I see them being a potential good act together, with Bob as the crazy hyper-intelligent type, with Owen's cocky heel shtick beside it. Gunns lose the belts, and hopefully this team can elevate the belts a bit.
Winners: Owen & Backlund
1-2-3 Kid Vs. Hakushi
This replaces Owen Vs. Davey as the hot action match on the undercard, serves to give Hakushi his first win on a big stage, and sets him up for some good stuff throughout the Summer.
Winner: Hakushi
Heavenly Bodies/Tatanka/IRS Vs. Headshrinkers/Adam Bomb/Bob Holly
The traditional "lets get a bunch of guys on the card" match, just a fun and quick way to open the show, babyfaces get the win.
Winners: Headshrinkers/Car Bombs ¬_¬
Final Thoughts:
Overall, not only do I think this is significantly better than what we got, but it's very plausible that they could have gone this direction just as easily. One of the major problems coming out of the real show was that there were absolutely no heels worth a fuck afterwards, as the babyfaces smoked through them all in the key matches. Here we elevate Razor as a babyface, get some awesome promos with Jerry Lawler, give Bret a hot issue which he sorely needed since he spent his 1995 in the midcard, create a hot new heel in Lex Luger, we give Yoko some heat, we don't eviscerate Bigelow, Taker gets a notch on his belt and MUCH needed good match, the tag titles are set up nicely on an important team, Hakushi heads into the Spring with some steam, and the Diesel/Michaels story gets its blowoff.
And more importantly, no Harris Twins or King Kong Bundy.
Friday, 25 July 2014
Analyse This - The Failure Of The Invasion
There are three major elements to consider when looking at what happened to piss away such amazing potential - The Fans, The Stars, and The Booking.
The Fans
Looking at the facts and figures, the WWF was starting to lose momentum in early 2001. Ratings had began to fall, even if slightly, from their peak. Things were getting stale on top, and people following closely knew it. WCW clearly would have filled this void, had it been executed the way most fans would like it. But I want to touch on something modern fans may lose sight of.
Back then, in the days of wrestling magazines, talent jumping back and forth, and two powerful national promotions, fan allegiance to the WWF or WCW was almost tribal. No matter if you watched both, you had a side that you grew up on, or fell in love with first, that deep down you rooted for. WCW fans hated the WWF and anything that resembled it. WWF fans were told to never accept WCW. It bred a visceral hatred within millions of people.
When WCW was purchased, and early mentions of WCW matches or shows were made, they were booed out the building by WWF fans. Ultimately, casting WCW as babyface in the early going was a huge mistake, and the first misread of many.
Everybody remembers the famous Booker/Bagwell stinkfest from Tacoma on Raw, the match that caused Vince McMahon to completely change course and bring in ECW to "save" the invasion angle. And as nice a moment as that was, at the time and in hindsight, the fact they even had to do that so early into the WCW angle is appalling. And with even a minute of analytical thought, how they thought Booker Vs. Bagwell was a good idea blows my mind.
WWF fans didn't want WCW Vs. WCW on their time. Take that shit to TBS, it's second rate, it's garbage, it's inferior. The WWF had conditioned these people to despise this for years. And now, that's what you are presenting them, and you wanted people to cheer. Instead, the Tacoma crowd violently turned on the match and direction of the angle. But in a major faux pas, WWF saw that and took it as a sign that the WCW brand was too damaged, and that there wasn't money in the WWF Vs. WCW story. But there was. That was the dream for years.
And as it turned out, the dream alone, even with a terrible build, helped do the best non-WrestleMania buyrate of all-time at the Invasion Pay-Per-View. Conflict they liked. Conflict they believed. Conflict they wanted. The people just didn't want what you gave them. The fans were not the problem. They were ready to see the dream. There was just something massive missing.
The Stars
WWF Vs. WCW relies on one thing. Stars Vs. Stars. That's the fantasy that fans had argued about for years, read about in magazines, and always wanted to see. The ultimate "what would happen" scenario.
And therein lies the major issue. WWF wasn't willing to get the stars. They did in the end anyway, but Goldberg, Flair, Steiner, Nash, Sting, DDP, Booker T and many more of the potential difference makers were under Time Warner deals, and were offered buyouts at 30 cents on the dollar, hoping the WWF would come calling with contracts for the guys and help offset the costs. This meant the WWF would have to make massive offers in order to convince the WCW wrestlers sitting at home, collecting hundreds of thousands of dollars, that they should get off the couch and take bumps.
And as it turned out, that wasn't a game WWF was willing to play. Booker and DDP (who has since said he lost $487,000 by making the deal) were happy to take the gamble of the buyout and a comparitively low WWF offer to be part of the angle. The others weren't.
When it comes to the stars needed to make it really work, WWF came in without the ammunition. And while we can wax lyrical about all the guys, Goldberg was the one that mattered. The discussion starts and ends with him. Bischoff would have been great for the promos and the heat. Flair would have been great for the identity. Sting and Steiner would have been tasty bonuses. But the big money was in Goldberg.
When looking at the Time Warner deal and the amount needed to get Goldberg, you were looking at paying him anywhere from 3 to 6 million dollars. The company could easily afford it, and the reason stars get paid more is because they produce more. At that time, Goldberg was worth every penny, because his market value dictated it, and the potential was there to make it back tenfold. Goldberg without WWE wasn't worth 6 million dollars. Goldberg with WWE was worth a boatload more in 2001. But a few issues popped up. While logic lets you justify that contract, the wrestlers on the winning side making significantly less were likely not so eager to.
Nowadays, it's different if Brock Lesnar and The Rock, guys who were considered successes outside the business, come in and get big money with the hopes of shifting buyrates, because the rest of the guys can't compare themselves to that success. That's okay. But in their minds, the comparison to Goldberg does nothing but piss them off. The salary structure is gone.
So there's the dilemma that kills it. You either spend a shitload on buying contracts, paying (some of) the WCW guys more than the WWF crew and pissing them off royally, or you do what they did, and hold out.
Granted, the WWF guys would have had nowhere to go. But for the long term health of the company backstage, that creates a poisonous atmosphere, rife with bitter feeling amongst colleagues. Jealously. Undercutting. Sounds just like WCW.
The catch-22 here certainly makes it difficult to get the stars you need. But lack of star power wasn't the only reason it was fucked.
The Booking
You could, I suppose, wait until all those contracts expired and sign the guys like they ended up doing anyway. But does that really fly?
Unfortunately, the answer is probably no. At that time, the business moved so fast. A week was like a month. Four months felt like a year. A year was a lifetime. Things evolved so fast you had to strike while the iron was hot. But for that reason, it was never going to work. You had to do the angle there and then in 2001, while the product, the news of the sale and the hatred in the fans was there, when the stars were still relevant and not nostalgic retreads.
As mentioned, casting them as babyfaces was a mistake. Putting Shane with them was another mistake.
The only way it could have worked was to keep it the way it was. The "evolution" of WCW died the second it was purchased. This kind of angle, as much as it is about the personalities, is also about the bigger picture. You are pitting image Vs. image, history Vs. history, that is what is selling. Once you change the image to fit a WWF guy in there, the fundamental element of what people were paying to see was gone. Down the line, four to six months in, there is money in a turncoat. But the leader of WCW having the last name McMahon? Not gonna work.
I also think that you make a mistake ever lying to the people. Even if people know wrestling is a work, nobody ever questioned that the WWF and WCW hated each others guts for real. That's the raw, once in a lifetime emotion that does the biggest PPV number ever. Once you give them something they can't buy into, something that takes it into the realm of just another WWF angle, while it may not kill it, it does more damage than good.
Let's not forgot egos. Obviously Vince, Kevin Dunn, and all the WWF guys, even though they purchased WCW, and owned the company, still had a grudge, and was reluctant to put it over as an equal. I don't care what anybody says, the Undertaker was fucking unbearable during this time, burying DDP, Kanyon, Booker T, Mike Awesome, Sean O'Haire, Chuck Palumbo and others, both on and off screen. The locker room being worked up could make for great on-screen chemistry. Letting the WWF guys slaughter the WCW crew maliciously was bad business.
WCW has to be equal in perception. A massive threat. WCW.Com, post WWF-purchase, ran an article with Stacy Keibler, referring to her as being signed by "the now-defunct WCW". An interview with Gregory Helms on WCW.Com noted that the WWF was the big time and he was so glad to be a part of it. Same writers on both website. WWF.Com selling WCW shirts. This is the kind of shit that would get you a knuckle sandwich from Bill Watts back in '84. Attention to detail was lacking, big time.
Their initial idea to do essentially a brand split, and maintain WCW as its own TV show, was nice on paper. But TNN wasn't so hot on a WCW show. Logically, they could have expanded Heat on MTV, since nobody gave a shit about that show anyway. How did "Excess" make air in 2001 when WCW couldn't, by the way? Ultimately the WCW brand looked to TNN like it fell out of a dog's ass, and they just didn't want that show. Believe it or not, before the Booker/Bagwell match, the plan was for the Vince and Linda divorce angle to split everything down the middle, to give Raw to "WCW", and have all WWF/Alliance wrestlers in the first ever draft, so "WCW Raw" would actually be half WWF guys, and "WWF Smackdown" was half WCW guys.
A WCW show on it's own, or even the horrible half-and-half draft idea, faces the same issues - without the iconic stars, it's stillborn. And in the end, without giving people the stars they first think of when the letters "WCW" enter their mind, there is only so well a TV show or an invasion angle is going to do, even perfectly booked. In an ideal world, if you could do anything you wanted, you'd deal with it significantly differently...
The Dream
Jim Cornette's Guest Booker, while highly questionable for a lot of his ideas, did have the best idea I've heard for how to acknowledge the sale. Be honest. Vince bought it. The war is, in reality, over.
And by the way, in my ideal world, Steve Austin doesn't turn heel at Mania when you're bringing in WCW. Why the fuck would you ever think you need a new top heel when WCW is coming in for Christ's sake?
From day one, the WCW guys should be completely isolationist. Vince cuts his glorious "I rule the world" speech that he'd no doubt practiced for twenty years. No Shane McMahon, no "somebody else owns it". But a harsh reality soon becomes apparent concerning his new purchase. The WWF guys want nothing to do with these motherfuckers. No sharing a locker room, no trust, no respect, nothing. They hate them being on their turf.
And more importantly, WCW is now in Vince's building. And they're fucking pissed at Vince McMahon and the WWF for killing their company. Some of the biggest names in the business, WCW to their core, united.
You have the big stand-off, guys like Flair, Booker, DDP, Sting, Steiner in the crowd or at ringside, Austin, Triple H, Taker, Angle, Jericho, the whole WWF locker room, on the ramp, Vince in the ring in between it all, and McMahon slowly starts to realise he's actually got a major problem on his hands. You create an immediate divide, steeped in real tensions, and you don't show all your cards at once. What is Vince going to do?
As things go on, Vince decides not to book WCW wrestlers on the show, because he's afraid of what could happen. He "ices" them, until he can figure out what to do. But WCW, who are employed, have carte blanche to show up when they want and do damage. Serious damage. Vince is trying to play peacemaker, and failing miserably. He declares that nobody from either side is to have any physical contact with the other until he says otherwise. But of course, WCW has other plans.
Right as McMahon is making his declaration, Eric Bischoff shows up as the ultimate outsider, personally employed by the WCW guys, and not the WWF, as their "strategic advisor". Some of the best promos and angles in history can now begin.
Bischoff in the crowd, surrounded by WCW guys, cutting a promo on Vince McMahon and the WWF, vowing revenge. Imagine. While Vince has disgust for WCW, and doesn't know what to do about the wrestlers yet, he utterly despises Bischoff, and it begins to cloud his judgment further, insulting the WCW stars directly. Bischoff's presence only intensifies Austin further, the guy who fired him is now on the scene.
At the same time, the WCW guys are chomping at the bit. Booker T calling himself the best World Champion there is and that Austin is a fraud. Scott Steiner threatening to kill Vince and his family. Ric Flair cutting a promo on anything that moves.
Things are very clearly escalating. Regardless, on one fateful episode of Raw, McMahon orders an incredible fleet of security, the most we've ever seen, to not let any WWF wrestler touch a WCW wrestler, or vice versa, in any circumstances. Things are reaching a boiling point, but he is still going to try and contain this.
But Chris Jericho is found laid out backstage, and when he's asked what happened, he points the finger directly at WCW. McMahon's order has been ignored. Austin is furious, and since Vince doesn't want them to fight on his turf, we'll do it outside in the parking lot, where security can't stop it. Just visualise that fucking promo for a second. Austin challenging WCW to the first fight. Potentially incredible.
Vince runs to the ring, demanding Austin, the guy he's never been able to control, to stop. But the WWF has had enough. Years of insults back and forth, they're on our turf, one of our own has been attacked, and we want to fight. Of course, it doesn't happen. The WWF guys are ready in the parking lot, but WCW is nowhere to be seen. Suddenly, the doors to the building slam shut. The WWF guys are locked out.
Back in the arena. the not-employed by the WWF Bischoff hops the rail. Vince is livid. Security rushes to pull outsider Bischoff away from the ring, and succeeds. But Vince's attention is diverted, calling Bischoff every name under the sun on the mic, when from behind, for the very first time in a WWF ring, is Bill Goldberg. There is no way the crowd doesn't go ballistic. And he spears Vince McMahon to death.
The WWF guys break down the door. They're charging back in, Austin leading the way, to get to Bill Goldberg. Security bombards the scene, holding everybody apart, exactly as Vince ordered. And in a very important detail, Goldberg doesn't run away, he's fighting to get past security, a one man army in his own right. The scene is as wild as any ever seen. Jim Ross and Paul Heyman are going insane on commentary. And the show abruptly cuts to black.
It'll turn out, way down the line at a crucial moment, that Jericho is a mole, and never was attacked by WCW in the first place, his claim was simply to get the WWF worked up and out the building to allow Goldberg to get to Vince.
Vince McMahon declares all out war. He doesn't fire them, because he wants to squash them for good. And with Bischoff as the surefire heel heat magnet, WCW can stay one step ahead and keep the heat.
From this point, any manner of promos, confrontations, attacks, Nexus debut-style ringside destructions, ANYTHING, is fair game. Keep it tense, don't do interpromotional matches on TV unless it's rare and a very big deal. The anticipation of violence and conflict is key. Make people WANT it. Give them just enough to make them want more. You can do a major beatdown angle where the WCW absolutely destroys the WWF, nWo style, so long as Austin isn't there. You can have the WWF catch a hit-and-run angle and beat the fuck out of an O'Haire and Palumbo the way they did, but WWF moments of victory are rare in the beginning. Austin and Goldberg, despite a mutual desire to fight, never touch, even when war breaks out. Not until the Pay-Per-View you want to do that match on, do they ever make contact.
Whichever direction you wish to take it - what a platform you'd have, huh? Sound good? Sound like a blueprint that could sell a Pay-Per-View or six?
Wake Up Call
It's just a dream. We all had ideas. But the realities of the world in 2001 didn't allow something like this, not even close. The problem for the WWF was that this is the stuff people wanted. For years they salivated at the thought, and they never truly believed they would. And then it happened. The sale heard around the world, and fans couldn't help but think big. Because it was big...potentially the biggest they would ever see.
Unfortunately for all of us in 2001, we found out that dreams don't always come true.
Wednesday, 23 July 2014
The WWE Network - A Lesson In "Value"
I've been mulling over an article on the WWE Network for a number of months, but held off because I was genuinely interested to see how things were going to play out first.
Back in January, I had a conversation with my good friend Tom Campbell about the WWE building their business around the Network, and immediately brought up my feelings that this project was doomed to fail. Campbell, to my surprise, said I was the first person he'd heard be negative on it.
I'm sure I wasn't, but looking at how things are playing out, I'm more baffled that people didn't see this coming. Looking at the basic principles and mathematics, it's an awful premise. Let's evaluate:
The biggest audience WWE gets is 4 million viewers, give or take, for Raw (in the US). For their Pay-Per-Views, they would average about 200,000 buys, with the exception of Rumble and Mania. This would be converting about 5% of free viewers into buyers.
Their plan was to cannabilize Pay-Per-View. As a result, the WWE Network, as it was laid out from almost the beginning, needed 1.5 million subscribers in the US alone to break even. TO FUCKING BREAK EVEN.
That's 37.5% of its Raw viewers. They were hoping to go from 5% to 37.5%, on the premise that putting Pay-Per-Views and archived content on at a lower price would create a significantly higher viewers-to-buyers conversion rate. On paper, it sounds difficult, but possible. But to believe this was going to work ignores a fundamental aspect of why Pay-Per-Views weren't doing better in the first place.
The vast majority of those free viewers are not conditioned, and haven't been for some time, to spend money on wrestling. They'll tune in for free, granted, but most of them don't separate from their cash to see more of it on their television. They get 3 hours of Raw every single week, and seldom is there a show where, at some point, it isn't dragging a bit. 3 hours is more than enough for the casual fan, and even if it wasn't, and were looking for an extra dose of wrestling, they also get a bonus two hours of Smackdown for free as well. Why would that fan, Mr. John Q. Walmart if you will, possibly want to pay for more? To see the Pay-Per-Views? Value doesn't work that way, and that's been historically proven.
WWF's In Your House series was supposed to be a cheaper alternative for major Pay-Per-Views, and it failed, because while the idea of attracting people that didn't buy before is nice, none of them did, because they weren't conditioned to. Meanwhile, the consistent buyers purchased the show in lower numbers, because they saw them as missable. Cheaper. Less important. Less value = fewer buys. When the In Your House shows were raised from 20 dollars to 30 dollars in September 1997, in line with the major shows, they didn't do any less buys, and they made 50% more money.
People will buy WrestleMania whether it's ten dollars or fifty dollars, because the buying audience that's there sees its value. And value does not come in dollar figures, it comes in your personal sense of gain, which stems from passion you have for the medium, and the importance you place on the item (in this case PPV/Network) in context to it.
WWE has NEVER convinced 1.5 millions fans in the US to purchase WrestleMania, the most valuable thing they sell. 1.5 million subscribers was a fantasy, a number they didn't have a prayer of reaching, at least at first. WWE announced 667,000 subscribers in their first conference call discussing figures. Consider again that a chunk of the more passionate overseas fans figured out how to get it as soon as, and it makes you question what the true American number is.
On July 31st, WWE is announcing the updated number of subscribers. Anything less than 850,000 should be considered horrifying, but I will be very, very surprised if it's that high. There is potential for growth when it gets launched internationally, don't get me wrong. The British market is thriving for wrestling, they're the ones who dominate WrestleMania and Raw, flying across the world to be part of the product and express themselves, the latest breed of "ECW fan". They are willing to spend the most money on the product out of anyone in the world right now.
In addition, Japan is an interesting nut to crack, especially if KENTA gets some traction in the WWE. But as the Network expands, so do the costs, and the necessary number of subscribers to make it all fly.
The Network is not the XFL, a "nice-to-have". They have changed the face of how they operate their core business. As a result, I'm surprised they aren't pushing the Network harder. The last two weeks they've done a fairly serious sell for it, but given how much constant verbal fellatio we had to put up with about Tout and Twitter a couple of years ago, which made nobody any money at all, it's baffling to me why there isn't a new video package every week on Raw detailing a historic moment, match or television show, giving people a taste of something distinctly different every time, saying they can only see it in full on the Network.
Pay-Per-Views should be more important than ever in terms of promotion, but they'd rather spent valuable TV time on the Fandango/Layla/Summer Rae fiasco than focus more seriously on reasons to separate fans from cash for the monthly megashows. The television needs more focus. Things have been a bit better lately, but they need to tighten up what we're seeing. When you have so much time to fill, it's harder than ever to create a perfect product, but there is very little in the WWE that seems important of late.
We have some rising stars, but outside the key 6 or 7 guys and the World Title, everything else is filler - guys treading water, fighting for unimportant belts they've all held before that didn't get them anywhere the first time. This needs to change. And it can. Whenever people think back to the time they loved wrestling the most, they almost always talk about how much things meant back then. How important something was portrayed as being. In those moments, people attached great personal value to the product. That doesn't exist to many people today. They follow it, but the high stakes that the product thrived on in years past is gone. A lot of it is due to the same talent being in the same positions for so long. Results matter far less when the consequences are negligible.
While Vince McMahon is pulled in a million different directions, has countless masters to serve, and is hellbound, till the day he dies, to do it all his way, he surely hasn't lost sight of the fact that separating fans from cash is, was, and will always be what the wrestling business is really about. And he'd better figure out how this Network is going to go about doing that real soon, because it's going to take a lot more than Jerry Lawler's begging like a homeless man to recondition a million people.
Back in January, I had a conversation with my good friend Tom Campbell about the WWE building their business around the Network, and immediately brought up my feelings that this project was doomed to fail. Campbell, to my surprise, said I was the first person he'd heard be negative on it.
I'm sure I wasn't, but looking at how things are playing out, I'm more baffled that people didn't see this coming. Looking at the basic principles and mathematics, it's an awful premise. Let's evaluate:
The biggest audience WWE gets is 4 million viewers, give or take, for Raw (in the US). For their Pay-Per-Views, they would average about 200,000 buys, with the exception of Rumble and Mania. This would be converting about 5% of free viewers into buyers.
Their plan was to cannabilize Pay-Per-View. As a result, the WWE Network, as it was laid out from almost the beginning, needed 1.5 million subscribers in the US alone to break even. TO FUCKING BREAK EVEN.
That's 37.5% of its Raw viewers. They were hoping to go from 5% to 37.5%, on the premise that putting Pay-Per-Views and archived content on at a lower price would create a significantly higher viewers-to-buyers conversion rate. On paper, it sounds difficult, but possible. But to believe this was going to work ignores a fundamental aspect of why Pay-Per-Views weren't doing better in the first place.
The vast majority of those free viewers are not conditioned, and haven't been for some time, to spend money on wrestling. They'll tune in for free, granted, but most of them don't separate from their cash to see more of it on their television. They get 3 hours of Raw every single week, and seldom is there a show where, at some point, it isn't dragging a bit. 3 hours is more than enough for the casual fan, and even if it wasn't, and were looking for an extra dose of wrestling, they also get a bonus two hours of Smackdown for free as well. Why would that fan, Mr. John Q. Walmart if you will, possibly want to pay for more? To see the Pay-Per-Views? Value doesn't work that way, and that's been historically proven.
WWF's In Your House series was supposed to be a cheaper alternative for major Pay-Per-Views, and it failed, because while the idea of attracting people that didn't buy before is nice, none of them did, because they weren't conditioned to. Meanwhile, the consistent buyers purchased the show in lower numbers, because they saw them as missable. Cheaper. Less important. Less value = fewer buys. When the In Your House shows were raised from 20 dollars to 30 dollars in September 1997, in line with the major shows, they didn't do any less buys, and they made 50% more money.
People will buy WrestleMania whether it's ten dollars or fifty dollars, because the buying audience that's there sees its value. And value does not come in dollar figures, it comes in your personal sense of gain, which stems from passion you have for the medium, and the importance you place on the item (in this case PPV/Network) in context to it.
WWE has NEVER convinced 1.5 millions fans in the US to purchase WrestleMania, the most valuable thing they sell. 1.5 million subscribers was a fantasy, a number they didn't have a prayer of reaching, at least at first. WWE announced 667,000 subscribers in their first conference call discussing figures. Consider again that a chunk of the more passionate overseas fans figured out how to get it as soon as, and it makes you question what the true American number is.
On July 31st, WWE is announcing the updated number of subscribers. Anything less than 850,000 should be considered horrifying, but I will be very, very surprised if it's that high. There is potential for growth when it gets launched internationally, don't get me wrong. The British market is thriving for wrestling, they're the ones who dominate WrestleMania and Raw, flying across the world to be part of the product and express themselves, the latest breed of "ECW fan". They are willing to spend the most money on the product out of anyone in the world right now.
In addition, Japan is an interesting nut to crack, especially if KENTA gets some traction in the WWE. But as the Network expands, so do the costs, and the necessary number of subscribers to make it all fly.
The Network is not the XFL, a "nice-to-have". They have changed the face of how they operate their core business. As a result, I'm surprised they aren't pushing the Network harder. The last two weeks they've done a fairly serious sell for it, but given how much constant verbal fellatio we had to put up with about Tout and Twitter a couple of years ago, which made nobody any money at all, it's baffling to me why there isn't a new video package every week on Raw detailing a historic moment, match or television show, giving people a taste of something distinctly different every time, saying they can only see it in full on the Network.
Pay-Per-Views should be more important than ever in terms of promotion, but they'd rather spent valuable TV time on the Fandango/Layla/Summer Rae fiasco than focus more seriously on reasons to separate fans from cash for the monthly megashows. The television needs more focus. Things have been a bit better lately, but they need to tighten up what we're seeing. When you have so much time to fill, it's harder than ever to create a perfect product, but there is very little in the WWE that seems important of late.
We have some rising stars, but outside the key 6 or 7 guys and the World Title, everything else is filler - guys treading water, fighting for unimportant belts they've all held before that didn't get them anywhere the first time. This needs to change. And it can. Whenever people think back to the time they loved wrestling the most, they almost always talk about how much things meant back then. How important something was portrayed as being. In those moments, people attached great personal value to the product. That doesn't exist to many people today. They follow it, but the high stakes that the product thrived on in years past is gone. A lot of it is due to the same talent being in the same positions for so long. Results matter far less when the consequences are negligible.
While Vince McMahon is pulled in a million different directions, has countless masters to serve, and is hellbound, till the day he dies, to do it all his way, he surely hasn't lost sight of the fact that separating fans from cash is, was, and will always be what the wrestling business is really about. And he'd better figure out how this Network is going to go about doing that real soon, because it's going to take a lot more than Jerry Lawler's begging like a homeless man to recondition a million people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)